Tuesday, October 19, 2010
Reflections on the Wilsonian Movement
Manela described how many former colonized countries attempted liberation movements. These movements were sparked by the idea that the United States was a champion of Wilsons theories. Many believed that the United States would use its newly aquired power to guarentee the right of all nations to govern themselves and not be dominated by a foreign power.Although, the United States did not live up to that lofty goal in 1919, she would continue to be a beacon of light that countries such as India, Korea, Egypt and China would continue to reach out too.
Just a few decades after World War 1 the United States would begin to fulfill this role of protector of freedom and self-determination. The conclusion of World War 2 left the United States in a position of global power this would leave it as the most powerful nation in the world. The United States global reach would stretch from Europe, to Asia and all across the Pacific Ocean. The United States has now assumed that role of international protector. Over the last 60 years the United States has proven that it is more than willing to use force to guarentee Wilsons principle of freedom and self-determination. Examples of this can be seen in Nicaragua, El Salvador,Panama,Kuwait,Iraq and Afghanistan.
Today, the Wilsonian movement is a national goal of the United States. Wilsons theories on self-determination have been used by the United States to fuel many fights for liberation throughout the world. If feel that this is one of the things that makes our nation great. Our belief in the right to national self-determination and our freedom of religion is what makes the United States the great nation that it is and will be. Mr. Manela's book is thoroughly enlightening and is a must read for everyone.
Monday, October 18, 2010
Kal Raustiala review
1. One argument deals with extraterritoriality which he argues can come in many different forms, but in these forms we see common themes: efforts to manage, minimize, or sometimes capitalize on legal differences abroad.
2. The second argument deals with intraterritoriality, which has long been a way for American law to facilitate the growth and power of the United States. Only a limited set of rights have applied in other U.S. territory. The map of American law is larger than the map of American territory Raustiala argues. But, the map of legal rights is smaller than the map of American territory.
In order to understand these two principles, one must understand doctrines of territoriality that extend all the way back to the Peace of Westphalia in 1648. Some of these doctrines include that a sovereign state within documented borders is controlled and governed by its own set of principles. This is an ideal of long standing, but today states are increasingly subject to scrutiny from the outside world, Raustiala argues.
Extraterritoriality:
As the United States grew larger, extraterritoriality became the way for the United States to "project a small realm of domestic law into a (weaker) foreign power's territory as a way to inoculate one's citizens against the strange, the different, and the dangerous." (21)
Intraterritoriality:
U.S. law has differed depending on place. The supreme court has long held that Constitutional protections do not extend abroad (Insular Cases). Then, during the Cold war, Americans and other Aliens were protected by the Bill of Rights against federal action even when overseas - a more universal conception of Constitutional rights. Then in 1990, a more Westphalian or "traditional" view of territoriality was taken by the American executive branch; it denied the protections of the Fourth Amendment to foreign criminals searched by American agents abroad. Thus, American allies were more likely to be the focus of postwar regulatory and military jurisdiction. (i.e., in Iraq, Afghanistan, etc.)
Main Argument:
From the 19th century to present day, the executive branch has looked at traditional sovereign principles to justify lack of full constitutional rights for overseas citizens/Aliens in American "territories." Their (Aliens') geographic location decisively determines the bundle of rights they enjoy.
In our current state of affairs, the reality of constitutional rights abroad is, "the Constitution only partly follows the flag."
Since the human rights' revolution after 1945, traditional notions of sovereignty have eroded. A new conception of sovereignty puts the rights of individuals above state sovereignty. Thus, the United States has attempted to use this "absence" of state sovereignty to gain greater leeway to detain and punish for the benefit of its self-interests. To argue that the Constitution does not apply as long as the executive branch is careful to act only in particular offshore places, strikes many Americans as a startling claim.
Critique to the orthodox view:
Some advocates for human rights' argue that when the Bill of Rights was written, the word "person" rather than "citizen" was deliberate. Also the absence of any geographical limitations for the Constitution was absent in the Bill of Rights. These arguments are valid in the sense that "person" was a deliberate choice, and a geographical limitation was not present, but not for the benefit of human rights'; rather these details of the Bill of Rights are in order to protect the self-interests of the executive branch of the United States.
Saturday, October 16, 2010
Global Musings on a picture
Tame Impala as a case study in Glocalization
Wednesday, September 29, 2010
Research topic
One topic that has been vital to globalization in the United States and globally in the twenty first century is Wal-Mart. To disagree that Wal-mart does not impact our global economy is crazy. Walmart serves customers and members more than 200 million times per week. Wal-Mart's international operations currently comprise 4,081 stores and 664,000 workers in 14 countries outside the United States.In 2010 the sales delivered outside the U.S. reached one hundred billion. Walmart had a fiscal year of $405 billion in sales, and Walmart employs more than 2 million associates worldwide. This number made Wal-mart number one on the Fortune 500 businesses.
My research topic or question is how does the mass globalization of Wal-mart impact the economy. For this I could look at both pros and cons of Wal-mart, both in the United States and in other courties. There is many things I can look at while also looking at the economic impact of the globalization of Wal-mart. For example, how it effects factory workers, food production, global factories, and global outsourcing. Another is the impact of shifting production to cheap labor markets overseas.
The reason I am so interested in this topic is I like how this effects the people of today and not something that has happened. The globalization of Walmart is happening, the company is growing and continues to grow every year. Another thing that interest me is how big Wal-mart actually is, and the impact it has on the global economy. Walmart that was created in 1962 grew to the number one business in fifty years.
Some smaller question I could bring up in my paper is:
· How does making production overseas effect the United States?
· What is the positives of Walmart globalizing?
· What are the negatives of Walmart globalizing?
· Why is China such important factor for Walmart?
· What countries did Walmart move to first and why?
· What does the future look like for walmart in the global perspective?
References
Fishman, Charles. 2006. The Wal-Mart effect: how the world's most powerful company really works-- and how it's transforming the American economy. New York: Penguin Press.
Smith, Hedrick, and Rick Young. 2005. Is Wal-Mart good for America? [Alexandria, Va.]: PBS Video.
Kammen, Glenn D., Robert B. Reich, Ruth Milkman, Edna Bonacich, Michael Mann, David A. Smith, Denise H. Froning, et al. 2005. Working world. Way we live : Introduction to sociology, 14. Pasadena, Calif: Intelecom.
"The Movement of Labor." New York Times 03 Aug. 2003: 7. Academic Search Complete. EBSCO. Web. 29 Sept. 2010.
Gereffi, Gary, and Michelle Christian. "The Impacts of Wal-Mart: The Rise and Consequences of the World's Dominant Retailer." Annual Review of Sociology 35.1 (2009): 573-591. Academic Search Complete. EBSCO. Web. 29 Sept. 2010.
First research proposal
How is the United States able to pull such a bold move with the "weaponization of outerspace?" One argument is a "visible city and a visible law allow no space from which either of them is to be seen." In other words, nations that are under the spell of our intra-connected, capitalistic, globalized way of life, cannot see nor can they understand a "city saturated with control."
With this notion of "city" and "law" both coinciding with one another in their visible states an inherent invisibility of spatial relations, uniqueness, democracy, and opinion all become relative to the citizens of said "law" and "city." With the invisibility of "city" and "law," the United States is able to garnish enough momentum for arguably their final push to save American Exceptionalism, and ultimately, the capitalist style of world production (in other words, to save their self-interests); this final push of momentum to save the "American Dream" is the controlling of a new "frontier" or "city," outerspace. With the already facilitated notion of the fusion of "law" and "city," invisibility is the chief support system that can possibly help the United States add one final push to their hegemonic, controlling domination in our current globalized society - the sovereignty to control outerspace, and thus leading to its build up of military arms.
This is just the beginning to my proposal. I will have an updated proposal with a working bibliography published onto the blog sometime this weekend.
Thanks, JT Liverman